Located in a really crappy strip mall you can't make a left turn into, currently moated off by some vague road construction project, it doesn't have a lot of curb appeal. But the food inside is definitely above average.
My friends and i went here for the first time since they closed from the fire. Staff was very accommodating, let us take back an extra order that we had made by mistake and is a BYOB place. The pizza was very good and was cooked perfectly, unlike the other pizza place around that tends to overcook the pizza from time to time. Lived in the area for 22 years and highly recommend Atilios.
In my neverending quest for the best cheesesteak in Toms River, it's only fitting that on the verge of moving an hour and a half away, I finally got around to Attilio's.
Sadly, I won't have too many more of these, because there are only so many cheesesteaks I can justify eating in the span of three weeks, but the one or two I will should definitely be from here.
Oh, also - they have excellent soups, and a pretty decent Cobb salad. I haven't tried the pizza, but being the oldest pizza place in town, I have to assume they do that right as well.
All of this can be fixed. "Please go heavy on the onions and mayo, and light on the peppers." Et, voila. An excellent cheesesteak, which by the way, is perfectly good when served plain, without adjustment or special requests.
The bread is excellent, and the sandwiches are slightly toasted to add a satisfying crunch. Made with white American mixed into the steak, which seems to be of a higher quality than several other nearby spots, I really can't find much to complain about. And yet... There is one thing.
I love you guys best pizza I have ever had. I always order from this amazing pizzeria. Staff is very friendly and I have been a customer for 17 years even before I had my kids for any occasion I would order from Atilois. My kids love love this pizzeria
Always good food and service.
Any topping you add to the sandwich is an additional 50¢. Not really that big a deal, but on my most recent trip, I ordered one with lettuce, tomato, onions, and hot peppers. Half a dollar each bought a ton of lettuce and hot peppers, but only two slices of tomato and three or four measly rings of raw onion. So, the blanket pricing approach to toppings wasn't exactly equitable. As an aside, I also asked for mayo, which they do not charge for, and it was applied somewhat sparingly, as though it were made from Iranian Beluga caviar and gold.
Best pizza and service in town!
Attilio S Pizzeria And Restaurant is a US Meal Delivery based in Toms River, New Jersey. Attilio S Pizzeria And Restaurant is located at 941 NJ-166, Toms River, NJ 08753, USA.
Please contact with Attilio S Pizzeria And Restaurant using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find Attilio S Pizzeria And Restaurant opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.
Find Meal Delivery in Toms River